Prohibition of abuse in Banking Acts and Practices Under U.S. Law: A Comparative Analysis with Iran's Legal System

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 PhD student in private law, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.

2 Associate Professor of Private Law, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Banking contracts, which are among the most commonly used standard contracts, are established between the credit institution (in a general sense) as the master party to the contract and the consumer. The adhesive nature of these contracts, combined with the complexity of their provisions and the dominant position of the credit institution, creates opportunities for potential abuse by the stronger party involved in the agreement. However, it is not always the case that consumers are exploited; information asymmetry can sometimes have the opposite effect, leading to moral hazards on the part of the consumer. Following the financial crisis of 2007-2008, the term "abuse" entered the legal and financial literature of the United States, largely due to the Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. The inadequacy of existing regulations in preventing the crisis, along with the failure to effectively address the financial turmoil, prompted a comprehensive review of the mechanisms for managing financial markets, particularly concerning credit contracts and the provision of financial facilities. In addition to establishing the Office of Financial Protection for Consumers, the aforementioned Act empowered this office to identify and prosecute abusive financial practices and actions. In this article, a descriptive-analytical approach is employed to examine the background and origins of abuse. The discussion includes the concept and enforcement of prohibitions within the legal system of the United States of America. Furthermore, the article evaluates existing mechanisms and examples in Iranian law in relation to the aforementioned legal framework. Finally, the expansion and enhancement of existing mechanisms within the domestic legal system to address the abuse of the more powerful party in a contract, along with a reference to general principles and the initiation of new approaches to consumer protection, can be inferred.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1. Abhari, H., Fallah Khariki,M. (2020).Unfair Terms in Electronic Commercial contracts in Iranian law and Europe, Comparative Law Quarterly. 4(5),pp.9-34. [In Persian]

    Adel,M., Shams-Allahi,M.(2018).Unfair terms in consumer contracts,Private Law Research,7(25),pp. 205-234. [In Persian]

     

    Ansari, A.(2011).Abuse of emergency with an approach to Imam Khomeini's jurisprudential thought. Matin Research Journal,13(55),pp.26-50.[In Persian]

     

    Abdipour,I.(2009).Abusing the dominant economic situation.Islamic Law,6(21),pp.125-155.[In Persian]

     

    Bagheri,M., Rahmani,S.(2017).Protection of consumer rights in the banking system.Tehran:Research School of Money and Banking.[In Persian]

     

    Bagheri, M., Rahmani, S.(2020).Protection of consumer rights in the country's banking system with a focus on credit contracts. Legal Research Quarterly,23(92), pp.43-70.[In Persian]

    Baily, N.M, Litan, R.E and S. Johnson, M.(2008). The Origins of the Financial Crisis, Business and Public Policy, November 2008. PP.1-48.

    Barikloo,A.(2003).guarantee of legal enforcement of abuse of the emergency situation of the contracting party.Legal Thoughts.1(4), pp. 25-45.[In Persian]

     

    Canzona,S.J.(2018).“I’ll Know It When I See It”:Defending the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s Approach of Interpreting the Scope of Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Acts or Practices (“UDAPP”) Through Enforcement Actions. Journal of legislation,45(3),pp.60-80.

     

    Carey,A.(2014) Abusive:Dodd-Frank Section 1031 and the Continuing Struggle to Protect Consumers. St. John's Legal Studies Research,Vol 85,pp.1104-1146.

     

    Chopra, R.(2021 October 19).CONSUMER FIN. PROT. BUREAU,Statement of the CFPB on the JPay Enforcement Action. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/statement-of-cfpb-director-rohit-chopra-on-the-jpay-enforcement-action/

     

    Chopra,R.(2024). Enforcing the Post-Financial Crisis Ban on Abusive Conduct. U.C. Irvine L. Rev 14 (2),pp.625-653.

     

    Corrigan, P.(2015). 'Abusive' Acts and Practices: Dodd-Frank's Behaviorally Informed Authority Over Consumer Credit Markets and its Application to Teaser Rates. New York University Journal of Legislation and Public Policy,18, pp.125-183.

     

    Demyanyk, Y.,Van Hemert,O.(2009).Understanding the Subprime Mortgage Crisis,Oxford University Press.

    https://fcic-static.law.stanford.edu/cdn_media/fcic-docs/2009-05 04%20Demyanyk%20Understanding%20the%20Subprime%20Mortgage%20Crisis.pdf

     

    Elsan, M.(2013).Laws of Central Bank. Tehran:Research School of Money and Banking.[In Persian]

     

    Elsan,M.(2020). Electronic Commerce Law.Tehran: Samat.[In Persian].

     

    Elsan,M. Mazloomi,S., Fathi, M.(2022).Abuse of rights in banking contracts. Private Law.19(40),pp.1-24.[In Persian]

     

    /Equity stripping,legalmatch.com, https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/equity-stripping-lawsuits.html

     

    Farzin-vash, A.,Barkhordari,S. (2010).global experiences of dealing with the financial crisis and lessons for Iran's economy,8(127),pp.116-141.[In Persian].

    FDIC.(2022).Unfair, Deceptive and Abusive Practices-Federal Trade Commission Act/Dodd-Frank Act.

     

    Fred.(2024,June25). Federal Funds Effective Rate. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FEDFUNDS

    FTC Policy Statement on Unfairness.(1980).https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/ftc-policy-statement-unfairness

     

    FTC Policy Statement on Deception.(1983). https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/ftc-policy-statement-deception

     

    Ghaffari-Farsani,B.(2019).Competition Laws and Civil Enforcement Guarantees,Legal Foundation: Mizan.[In Persian]

     

    Hosseini-Sadrabadi, I., Jamali. M.(1400).consumer rights in the banking system.Tehran:Mizan.[In Persian]

     

    Jaafari,A.(2020). Banking Laws, first volume.Tehran: Sahami Enteshar.[In Persian]

    Jafari-Langroudi, M.J(1999). Expanded on Legal Terminology. third volum.Tehran: Ganje Danesh. [In Persian]

    Karimi, A., Koshki, M.(2021).Imposed conditions in the contracts concluded between the owners of letters. Research Journal of Commerce.100, pp.229-256.[In Persian]

     

    Karimi, A., Shabani Kandsari, H.(2014).The logical relationship between the jurisprudential rule of La-Zarar and the logical rule of abuse of rights. Comparative Research Quarterly of Islamic and Western Laws,1(2),pp.135-166.[In Persian]

     

    Katouzian, N.(2018).General Rules of Contracts. Volume One.Tehran:Sahami Enteshar.[In Persian]

     

    Kazempour, S.J. (2013).Ways to support the weak side of the contract.Tehran:Fekrsazan.[In Persian]

     

    Lucas, L.A, Marec, A.D, Morton, J.C.(2016).“Abusive” Acts or Practices Under the CFPA’s UDAAP Prohibition. The Business Lawyer; Vol.71, pp.749-757.

     

    Makridis, C., Ohlrogge, M.(2022).Moving to Opportunity?The Geography of the Foreclosure Crisis and the Importance of Location. Journal of Economic Geography,22(1), pp.159–180.

     

    Mayerbrown(2023, May 02).CFPB’S POLICY STATEMENT ON ABUSIVE ACTS OR PRACTICES – SOME OBSERVATIONS. https://www.mayerbrown.com/en/insights/publications/2023/05/cfpbs-policy-statement-on-abusive-acts-or-practices-some-observations.

     

    Movahed., M.A.(1401).The Right and its Abuse.Tehran:Karnameh Publishing House.[In Persian]

     

    Nafcu.(2022).Unfair,Deceptive, or Abusive Acts or Practices(UDAAP),Issue Brief.

     

    O'Brien,ch.(2018). The CFPB’s Endaround, Cath. U. L. Rev. 67 (9),pp.365-387.

     

    Policy Statement(2023 April 03).On Abusive Acts and practices.CFPB. https://www.consumerfinance.gov/compliance/supervisory-guidance/policy-statement-on-abusiveness/

    Shahidi, M.(2001).Violation of Right, Legal Research,33 and 34,pp.31-62.

     

    Rahbari, E., Hasani Sangani,V.(2019).Cmopetition in the realm of Intellectual ownerships,vol II, Tehran: Samt.[In Persian]

    1. Rept. 111-176 -THE RESTORING AMERICAN FINANCIAL STABILITY ACT OF 2010. https://www.congress.gov/congressional-report/111th-congress/senate-report/176/1.

     

    Taqipourdarzi Naqibi,M.H., Muslimzadeh, F., Taleghan Ghafari, M(2023).protective rules in the consumer protection law in a comparative view with the civil law. Civil Law Knowledge,12(1),p.p 19-34.[In Persian]

     

    Tiffany, S.L.(2011). No More Abuse:The Dodd-Frank and Consumer Financial Protection Act’s Abusive Standard. Journal Consumer & Commercial Law,14,pp.118-133.  

     

    The Financial Crisis inquiry report.(2011).Final Report of the National Commission on the Causes of the Financial and Economic Crisis in the United States. Featured Commission Publications.

     

    UDAAP CFPB Manual.(2012).Unfair,Deceptive,or Abusive Acts or Practices,Unfair,Deceptive,or Abusive Acts or Practices.

     

    Whalen,R.C.(2008). The Subprime Crisis: Cause, Effect and Consequences Indiana State University, Scott College of Business, Networks Financial Institute NFI Policy Briefs 2008-PB-04.

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 18 August 2024
  • Revise Date: 17 October 2024
  • Accept Date: 21 November 2024

Share

How to cite

Statistics