The Role of Neuterization in The Welfare of Urban Animals, Comparative Study of Iran, Europe, Latin America

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of International Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Mazandaran , Babolsar, Iran.

2 PhD student in Private Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Some ethicists believe that the philosophy of animal rights considers the sterilization/neuterization of animals as a violation of the principle of respect for them, and therefore Trap-Neuter Return (TNR) programs are also impermissible. Because it seems that this act violates the natural rights and freedoms of animals. In response, the present research shows that the approach of animal welfare under certain conditions considers it justifiable to harm some animals (human or non-human) in order to prevent further harm to others. Based on the philosophy of animal rights, causing less harm to some animals to prevent more harm to others, as envisioned in TNR programs, is more compatible with considering the intrinsic value of both categories. Neutered urban animals can be accepted while they have value in their own right. The experience of European and Latin American countries also confirms this opinion. Although the methods of the pioneering countries are implemented to some extent in Iran, in Iran, TNR programs in line with animal welfare has received less attention. The purpose of this article is to investigate the legitimacy and then the impact of neuterization on the welfare of urban animals with descriptive-analytical method, while describing the laws and enforcement procedures in the countries under discussion. The method is to collect library and field materials (interview), during which the existing problems will be examined and suggestions will be made to solve them based on successful measures. As a result, first the concept of animal welfare and the related approaches, the advantages and disadvantages of neuterization will be described and then the experience of the countries in question will be discussed.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

  1.  

    Abrantes, R.; Rasmussen, R. (1977).  The evolution of canine social behavior, dogwise publishing.

     

    Aronson, Myla F. J. ; La Sorte, Frank A. ; Nilon, Charles H. ; Katti, Madhusudan; Goddard, Mark A.; et al. (April 2014). "A global analysis of the impacts of urbanization on bird and plant diversity reveals key anthropogenic drivers". Proceedings of the Royal Society B. 281 (1780): 20133330. doi:10.1098/rspb.2013.3330. PMC 4027400. PMID 24523278.

     

    Association of Pet Behaviour Counsellors (APBC) book of companion animal behavior, by Appleby, D. (editor) (2016). London, Souvenir Press Ltd.

     

    Baxter, M. R. (1983). Ethology in environmental design for animal production. Applied Animal Ethology, 9.

     

    Belsare, A.; Vanak, A. (2020). Modelling the challenges of managing free‑ranging dog populations, Nature Scientific Reports 10.

     

    Boonin, D. (2003). Robbing PETA to Spay Paul: Do Animal Rights Include Reproductive Rights? Between the Species 13(3).

     

    Bouwman, M. (2015). Animal sheltering in the Netherlands, Reaching out to the community, mantra on view hotel.

     

    Bowman Report. Global Desk—The Great Spay-Neuter Debate. Available online: https://bowmanreport.com/blogs/all-articles/global-desk-the-great-spay-neuter-debate.

    Brambell Report. (1965). Report of the technical committee to enquire into the welfare of animals kept under intensive livestock husbandry systems. London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.

     

    Broom, D. M. (1991). Animal welfare: concepts and measurement. Journal of Animal Science, 69.

     

    Broom, DM.; Faster, AF. (2015). Domestic animal behavior and welfare, CABI.

     

    BuRO. (2021). Advice from BuRO on the evaluation of the animals act (Utrecht:
    NVWA).

     

    Carmichael LE. ; Greene CE. (2006). Infectious Diseases of the Dog and Cat. 3rd ed. Philadelphia (PA), USA. WB Saunders.

     

    Cocia, R.I.; Rusu, A.S. (2010). Attitudes of Romanian pet caretakers towards sterilization of their animals: Gender conflict over male, but not female, companion animals. Anthrozoos 23.

     

    Dawson, J.K.; Howell, T.J.; Ruby, M.B.; Bennett, P.C. (2019). Throwing the baby out with the bath water: Could widespread neutering of companion dogs cause problems at a population level? Front. Vet. Sci.

     

    Forsberg CL, Persson G. (2007). A survey of dystocia in the Boxer breed. Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica, 21.

    Frank J. (2004). An interactive model of human and companion animal dynamics: the ecology and economics of dog overpopulation and the human costs of addressing the problem. Hum Ecol 32(1).

     

    Fraser, D., Weary, D. M., Pajor, E. A., & Milligan, B. N. (1997). A scientific concept of animal welfare that reflects ethical concerns. Animal Welfare 6.

     

    Friz D. (2003). The Problem of Stray Animals practical and effective management methods, The Foundation Mondo Animale Onlus Frontiers in Veterinary Science 4.

     

    Garde, E.; Marín-Vial, P.; Pérez, G.E.; Sandvig, E.M. (2022). A review and analysis of the national dog population management program in Chile. Animals 12.

     

    Glasser, C.L. (2021). Attitudes toward spay/neuter in the US Population: Urban/rural, cat/dog, and demographic differences. Anthrozoos 34.

     

    Griffin, B. (2009). Revisiting the basics: The importance of sterilization – that little ounce of prevention carries weight in the battle against animal homelessness. Animal Sheltering Magazine. http://www.animalsheltering.org/resource_library/magazine_articles/mar_apr_2009/shelter_medicine_the_importance_of_sterilization.html

     

    Gueseva, V. (2013). Dog Ownership through the Eyes of a Stray Dog: Property Rights and the Stray Dog Population. Undergraduate Honors Theses.

     

    International Companion Animal Management Coalition (ICAM). (2007). Humane dog population management guidance. http://icamcoalition.org

     

    Jackman J., Rowan A. (2007). Free-Roaming Dogs in Developing Countries: The Benefits of Capture, Neuter, and Return Programs. State of the Animals. https://animalstudiesrepository.org/sota_2007/10

     

    Jena N. P. (2017). Animal Welfare and Animal Rights: an Examination of some Ethical Problems, J Acad Ethics, Springer Science and Business Media Dordrecht.

     

    Johnston SD., Root Kustritz MV., Olson PNS. (2001). Canine and feline theriogenology. Philadelphia (PA), USA: WB Saunders; 2001.

     

    Kakati K. (2012). Street Dog Population Survey, Kathmandu, Final Report to WSPA.

     

    Kennedy, J. S. (1992). The new anthropomorphism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

     

    Khoshyari Hajibaba, R., Majdi, A. (2013). Protection of animals in Iranian laws and international documents". Medical Law Quarterly.  26. [in persian]

     

    Kiley-Worthington, M. (1989). Ecological, ethological, and ethically sound environments for animals: toward symbiosis. Journal of Agricultural Ethics. 2.

     

    Kisiel, L.M.; Jones-Bitton, A.; Sargeant, J.M.; Coe, J.B.; Flockhart, D.T.; Reynoso Palomar, A.; Canales Vargas, E.J.; Greer, A.L. (2016). Owned dog ecology and demography in Villa de Tezontepec, Hidalgo, Mexico. Prev. Vet. Med. 135.

     

    Klein, MK. (2007). Tumors of the female reproductive system. In: Winthrow SJ, Vail DM, editors. Withrow and MacEwen's Small Animal Clinical Oncology. 4th ed.  St. Louis (MO), USA: WB Saunders Elsevier.

     

    Krukonis G., Bar, T. (2008). evolution for dummies. wiley publishing inc.

     

    Lundmark Hedman, F., Berg, C., and Stéen, M. (2021). Whose interest matters when regulating animal welfare? a Swedish case study, Justice and food security in a changing climate. Wageningen: Wageningen Academic Publishers.

     

    Mondal, R.; Protopopova, A.; Bhadra, A. (2023). The human-animal bond and at-home behaviours of adopted Indian free-ranging dogs, Applied Animal Behaviour Science, Volume 268.

     

    Ortega-Pacheco, A.; Rodriguez-Buenfil, J.C.; Bolio-Gonzalez, M.E.; Sauri-Arceo, C.H.; Jiménez-Coello, M.; Forsberg, C.L. A. (2007). Survey of dog populations in urban and rural areas of Yucatan, Mexico. Anthrozoos 20.

     

    Pereira, M.A.A.; Gonçalves, L.A.; Evangelista, M.C.; Thurler, R.S.; Campos, K.D.; Formenton, M.R.; Patricio, G.C.; Matera, J.M.; Ambrósio, A.M.; Fantoni, D.T. (2018). Postoperative pain and short-term complications after two elective sterilization techniques: Ovariohysterectomy or ovariectomy in cats. BMC Vet. Res. 14.

     

    Price, E. O. (1984). Behavioral aspects of animal domestication. Quarterly Review Biology, 59.

     

    Reece JF, Chawla SK, Hiby AR. (2013). Decline in human dog-bite cases during a street dog sterilisation programme in Jaipur, India. Vet Rec 172(18).

     

    Reece JF, Chawla SK. (2006). Control of rabies in Jaipur, India, by the sterilisation and vaccination of neighbourhood dogs. Vet Rec 159(12).

     

    Reece, J. F, (2007). Rabies in india: an ABC approach to combating the disease in street dogs. Vet.Rec.161.

     

    Regan, Tom. (1983). The Case for Animal Rights. Berkeley: University of California.

     

    Regan, Tom. (2003). Animal Rights, Human Wrongs: An Introduction to Moral Philosophy. New York: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.

     

    Rollin, Bernard. (2006). Animal Rights and Human Morality (Third Edition). New York: Prometheus Books.

     

    Sallander, M.; Hedhammar, Å.; Rundgren, M.; Lindberg, J. (2001). Demographic data of a population of insured swedish dogs measured in a questionnaire study. Acta Vet. Scand. 42.

     

    Shahbazi, A. (2011).  Animal rights; theory and practice, Public Law Research, Volume 14, Issue 36. [in Persian]

     

    Stubbs, W.; Bloomberg, M.; Scruggs, S.; Schille, V.; Senior, D. (1993). Prepubertal gonadectomy in the domestic feline: Effects on skeletal,
    physical, and behavioral development. Vet. Surg. 22.

     

    1. Mannhart, T. Senders, T. Hoppenbrouwers, A. (2007). Steiger A catch-neuter-release project for free-roaming dogs and cats in Rhodes, Greece: Problem analysis and effectiveness of the strategy. Journal of American Veterinary Medical Association [JAVMA].

     

    Taghipoor A.  (2018). Criticism of the translation of the Council of Europe's law book, Critical Research. Journal of Humanities Texts and Programs. 50. [in persian]

     

    Tenzin, T., Ahmed, R., Debnath, NC., Ahmed, G., Yamage, M. (2015). Free-roaming dog population estimation and status of the dog population management and rabies control program in Dhaka City, Bangladesh. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 9(5).

     

    Totton. SC., Wandeler, AI., Ribble, CS. (2011). Stray dog population health in Jodhpur, India in the wake of an animal birth control (ABC) program. Preventive Veterinary Medicine 98.

     

    Vakil, A. (2020). Emergence of Transnational Approaches to Animal Welfare Law, Public Law Studies Quarterly, Vol. 50, No. 1.

     

    Von Gall, P., Gjerris, M. (2017). Role of joy in farm animal welfare legislation. Soc. Anim. 25 (2). doi: 10.1163/15685306-12341444

     

    Voogt, AM., Ursinus, WW., Sijm, DTHM., Bongers, JH. (2023). From the Five Freedoms to a more holistic perspective on animal welfare in the Dutch Animals Act. Front. Anim. Sci. 4. doi: 10.3389/fanim.2023.1026224

     

    World Health Organization/World Society for the Protection of Animals (WHO/WSPA) (1990): Guidelines for dog population management. WHO Document WHO/ZOON/ 90.165, Geneva.

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 28 August 2023
  • Revise Date: 20 October 2023
  • Accept Date: 28 November 2023

Share

How to cite

Statistics